Bowls said: I was never one of those dudes who gave him a cookie just because he sampled old records (actually CDs he bought from Tower) in a post-Swizz Beats era. How are those "H to the Izzo" type beats sounding today? He was never able to make his drums bang (he used Dre's "Xxplosive" kit/pattern like six times), his sampling was rigid, and his sources were boring and obvious. He didn't know how to do it well enough, so.....
People jumped all over his ass on here when he posed on the cover of Scratch holding a copy of Let's Get It On with a $15 price tag - "Look at him, flossing dollar-bin records, fuckin' cornball..." I didn't give a fuck then and I don't give a fuck now. I couldn't care less whether he sampled old records, CDs, low-bitrate RealAudio files or field recordings. The Blueprint knocks pretty much front-to-back and is, IMO, one of the greatest albums ever made. Kanye had a lot to do with that.
The Jon Brion collaboration was great and produced arguably his best work. Definitely the most musical, to my ears at least. But you knew immediately when the sound got thicker, because West was still supplying those anemic ass tracks that ALWAYS needed another element or two. Late Registration seemed like a natural expansion for Kanye's sound. But the shit he's been on the last few years? This latest "minimal" take on rap/pop? Why does this dude need five people to make a "minimal" sounding beat?
Oh and hip-hop is definitely producer driven, as is the electronic scene that Kanye's dabbled in. The thing is, damn near all these producers he employs can make those beats on their own. Besides a "vision" or whatever, I'm not exactly sure what Kanye himself can bring to the table production-wise. We're talking about a guy who had to farm out "Stronger" to Timbaland to "get the drums right."
In other genres, the producer doesn't customarily produce every note of music on a record he or she produces. How many instruments do you think Phil Spector played on River Deep, Mountain High? How do you think it would have sounded if Ike Turner had produced it? Would it have been as big a hit? Would it have been one of the landmark pop records of the 1960s? This is where the vision comes in. That vision can involve bringing in a dude like Jon Brion, or it can mean that, when you're sat there thinking, "I need these drums to hit as hard as Timbaland's", you think, fuck it, let's just call Timbo. More significantly, he answers, because you're Kanye.
Having a "vision" can also mean that, if you've got five people in a room all chipping in on a project, you need to have a) an intimate enough knowledge of the politics of the game to know how important it is to the other four dudes that they get their name on the record too, and b) the wisdom to know that if you start acting all "I put this together! ME!!", demanding 100% of the shine/credit/royalties, they might not sign off on it, and you end up having to cut a track that's key to your record. It cuts the other way as well - "If I use your beat on my record, I want a co-producer credit too" - a lot of record producers do nothing more than push a few faders, shout a few instructions and make sure they're in the control room long enough to claim a credit.
Dilla did that beat by himself and didn't get credit.
That's what I said;
Everyone knows Dilla produced Janet Jackson's Got 'Til It's Gone, for example
Politics.
Kanye needed three other people to make a beat that involved drums, a piano sample, and a vocal drop - and he credited them all.
Different situations.
Well, yeah. It might have started out sounding completely different, for example. [Co-producer X]'s work might not have been used at all, even though he started work on the track. [Co-producer Y] might have been the one who brought in the piano sample. [Co-producer Z] might have been the dude who got the drums to knock
just so. And Kanye might have been the dude that said, OK, now why don't we put it all together like this. The kind of thing a record producer might do, in other words. And everyone ends up being credited in the same way as contributors to the screenplay of a movie. Kanye might well have done very little of anything on the track. But the presence of other names in the credit field aren't irrefutable proof either way.
Oh and it's been confirmed that Kanye didn't do "All About The Benjamins." Curious to know which other beats his name has been attached to though.
Mo' Money, Mo' Problems was always rumoured to have been one of his.