bull_ox said:SPlDEY said:I've already watched that, and you're misinterpreting where he says:
"I???m not one of these people who has some kind of an agenda, like old is better and analogue is better and digital is bad. I don???t care, man. It is music. Music is supposed to make you feel good and that???s got to be the end of it. And if it doesn't make you feel good, it???s wrong, and if it does, then it???s right and that's it."
He states that he has no agenda, but Daptone studios make the records exactly how we want to make them, and implies that analog 8-track is still his personal preference.
You are misinterpreting what I said.
I know (as well as everyone else familiar with his music) that analog is his preference.
I'm saying that he no longer believes that it is the best/only way to record good music, like he did when he was young & naive.
I'm not criticizing you Bull Ox. All I'm doing is pointing out how you are slightly manipulating his words to fit your agenda. I understand what you are saying, I read what you read, and here is exactly where I disagree and agree with your interpretation of what he said.
You originally stated:
Gabe Roth makes great efforts to communicate that analog is not necessary to make great recordings now...
Then you made up a quote from him:
"I'm not one of those people who thinks old is better, analog is better..."
Your re-interpretation then states:
"..he no longer believes that it ("it" implying analog recording) is the best"
The reason why this is incorrect is that it implies that Gabe believes analog is not necessary to record funk 45s. Nowhere in that interview does he state that in fact his words and actions imply exactly the opposite. So I went to the transcript, and pasted his exact words. As far as his personal preference he mentions:
"..being in the studio with an eight track machine is amazing, it is a different process." - Gabe
then you correct yourself:
"he no longer believes that it is the best/only way to record good music"
I've never read anything from him talking about it being the only path "to record GOOD music". In the Big Daddy article he states:
" ..though digital recording is now very affordable and accessible, IT SUCKS SHIT FROM MY ASS." - Gabe
Which looks like an opinion that he has now from experience matured from. (This is where I agree with your interpretation.)
Hope that clears up the misunderstanding between us.
saludo,
- spidey