Really? That surprises me. I would figure you'd love them. I sure do in that I wish folks would get over their story already and focus in on the quality of their music. Instrument has some hip-hop-oriented instrumentals on it to boot.
They just don't have any rock and roll to them. They have lots of energy, they have a mystique, I'll give them all that. But they just don't have any sexiness or humor to what they do, it seems very neutered and neutral to me. Just how I see it. I have seen 'em live, and they are better than the records for sure.
" no sexiness and humor to what they do"....classic!
bman. did you read the article that came out on them in the dc city paper about a year and a half ago talking about how they were the puritans of rock and roll and that they killed rock & roll in general because of their "trying to do good" characteristics?
i was outraged by the article. shit to me was just a big poking match where the author that *wasn't even from dc was trashing dc's music by only covering half of the punk rock scene during that time. he didnt even mention bad brains.
imo, whats wrong with trying to convey a message in your music? that doesn't kill rock and roll.
however, telling people to not mosh and slam dance at a punk rock show.
with that said. fugazi is still my shit. then again, so is bad brains.
See, Bad Brains I can get with, and I remember that article as being a long diatribe on the level of "unless you smoke a lotta drugs and bed down with skanky groupies, you are not rock and roll and not keepin it real" which was just plain corny. That dude clearly had an axe to grind and it was just embarrassing to him and anyone that took him seriously.
I was careful to point out that Fugazi are just not for me, not that they just plain "suck". I do think their records are almost unforgivably dull, given the level of performance their live show generates, especially their rapport with an audience. Hey, I feel the same way about Sonic Youth...I understand the appeal of these acts, I just don't get excited by them or care to listen to their stuff because to me it's just dull.
And I have no problem with a message, but most of the Fugazi stuff I have heard is not message-heavy, I think the message is in how they do business and conduct themselves. And frankly, that I have IMMENSE respect for. But you and I probably differ about message-driven rock. I generally think that such an idea is silly and gets in the way of a musical idiom that is generally escapist. Even the MC5's 'political' stuff is fun and loud first, polemical second(and really, most of it is pretty cartoonish as opposed to actually political). But that's the beauty of a great big world!