Some people prefer the question and answer sessions ???unfiltered???, as faux_rills put it, ???I... would much rather hear some of the people responsible for it speak on it in their own words???. Completely valid. Personally I feel that the ???realness??? of the Q&A format can be retained by good journalism, and that a good article shouldn???t shy away from taking risks and offending somebody, possibly even the subject of the article.
Well, I didn't really mean to offer that as an end-all principle for music journalism; I devote a substantial portion of my life to consuming music writing, so I am by no means hostile to it.
But, given the abilities of most people associated with
WP, I would take a straight Q&A over some sort of a 'thinkpiece' written by one of them almost every time. There is some fantastically bad writing in there and there's no way around that fact.
I think you're over-exaggerating the bad qualities in the writing. The set of priorities of Wax Poetics readers/writers is different from the usual, and the contributors aren't completely composed of journalists, but is it really that much more terrible than your average URB article?
If you don't hold much alegience to the Q&A format, maybe you can you turn it around and offer a suggestion other than that. Instead of saying the writing is "fantastically bad", where do you find it lacking? What could you suggest to improve? (like Vitamin's suggestion of more incisive, creative article themes)
Is it more terrible than the average
URB article? I don't know, because it's been a good five years since I've cracked an issue of that magazine, but I supect not. That's setting the bar rather low, though.
Let me be clear: I am not wedded to the Q&A format in
all contexts, but in this context, given the quality of the pool of writers they have to draw from, I think that it is the best alternative. As you hinted at, most of the people writing for the magazine are not professionals; they're collectors long before they are writers, and no amount of 'constructive criticism' from me is going to change that.