Jimster said:
Junior said: Thread hijack, what say you on the Miles in general? Visionary or talented self marketer with a top ear for collaborators?
Good question.
Visionary with a top ear for collaborators. Visionary enough to not want to pigeonhole his style, to embrace other genres of music and hear how he could sound amongst it. Brave enough to risk his entire reputation and career by shifting styles because he was genuinely bored of playing the same stuff, no matter how good he was at it. To be battered by critics but then later apologised to. But also wise enough to recruit the correct people, people who would enable this sound, and hear where Miles could fit in - not try and do it all himself.
I don't think marketing or money was a driver for him at all, he just always had his ears open for the contemporary sounds. Not all of it works for me of course, but everything ain't for everyone. For example, I am not mad keen on Wayne Shorter over George Coleman whereas everyone else is. For me, that band had a perfet Coleman-shaped hole, wheras Shorter - granted, a more rounded musician - didn't fit as well. Again, his game is kinda not the droids I am looking for. "On The Corner" - a Strut sacred cow, it would appear. For me, some more emperors new clothes. Miles was out of it during this period and to me it sounds it.
Herbie of course has also tried the same style-shifts, with varying results. The thing with Herbie is, he never leaves his past behind, so even when he was at the height of his electro days in the mid-80s, he would still go to japan and do trio jazz gigs. I'd say Herbie has also chosen his collaborators...hmm... Less-well than Miles. Although some have been inspired. Norah Jones on Joni's "Court and Spark"? On paper it was a finger-crucifix for me but they hammered it.
Cheers for the considered answer J*m. From my scant knowledge I think he also got lambasted by purists bitd for his use of cutting and pasting sessions together to get the most complete performance? An approach that makes absolute sense to me but I think gave people a chance to challenge his "ability". Too lazy to google verification though.
I like On The Corner but I came at it from entirely sideways rather than a progress through Miles' career to this point (for many years I think the only Davis releases I was really familiar with were my beat up copy of Bitches Brew and my cassette of OTC - those crazy days before people's entire discographies were available at a click).
I'm with Gibbo on the lack of Coleman knowledge, I will get familiar.