Soulpower said:batmon said:
I wouldnt call him a genius.
As good as he was, he was expanding on existing styles of R&B/Soul/Funk and didnt really change the game or cause a paradigm shift IMO.
Rick James and Prince come to mind whom put a heavier stamp on the game in terms of cats that were multi-talented.
I think he very much deserves to be called genius ... it's a term that I don't use lightly.
Back in the 1960s and 1970s, only very few Soul singers actually wrote their own songs and arranged and orchestrated them .. Hutson is one of a few, and he is also a multi-instrumentalist. During his prime years, he wrote some exceptionally beautiful music for himself and other artists with little or no help from outside producers/arrangers/composers. And he did in fact have a huge impact on Soul music .. not so much over here in the States, but in the UK. One could argue that the soulful side of the Acid Jazz movement and Modern UK Soul (or "London Soul") from the late 1980s and throughout the 1990s was based on the sound that Hutson created .. which is why he is possibly the prime artist in the so called Rare Groove scene in the UK, and when he performed there a couple of years ago, he created an excitement among his fans that I have rarely seen in my career in this biz.
Hutson never achieved the level of fame that Rick James or Prince did ... which had a lot to do with the fact that he was never signed to a major label and he never enjoyed performing live. In fact, most of his hits that his fans love so much, he had never performed live until his European tour two years ago. The guy is a studio musician ... that's where he unleashes his creative energy, and you can't possibly judge his talents unless you have seen him work in this environment.
I think one could call Prince a musical genius for sure .. but Rick James? Sorry, I'm not convinced ... If you gave Rick some sheet music paper and a pen, I doubt he could have written out the arrangements for a 15-piece ensemble and string orchestra ..
I tend not place too much wieght on the number instruments a cat can play. Each cat can provide many things to the table regardless of string arrangments that the other cat cant. "He plays 12.......But He plays 20!"
I disagree that one cant judge a musicians ART unless i see him tinkering in his or her studio. Does one really need to be in the studio to appreciate Angela Winbush, Lionel Ritchie, Barry White, Stevie Wonder,Isaac Hayes, or Maurice Whites ART?
Good call on the UK love though.